Question 430
An auditee makes several claims after this quality audit observation: An auditor grades an assembly line against personal preferences rather than approved customer or standard criteria. Which proposed claim is least defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
A finding may be raised simply because the auditor would have designed the process differently. The unsupported claim would obscure the quality problem. The more defensible action is: Establish current applicable audit criteria before comparing actual evidence to requirements. This can be tested by: Match criteria versions, applicability decisions and representative test results.
Incorrect Answers
Use this proportionate audit response: Establish current applicable audit criteria before comparing actual evidence to requirements. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: A finding may be raised simply because the auditor would have designed the process differently.
Check the following evidence: Match criteria versions, applicability decisions and representative test results. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: A finding may be raised simply because the auditor would have designed the process differently.
Apply this quality-audit principle: Conformity is evaluated against valid criteria supported by objective evidence. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: A finding may be raised simply because the auditor would have designed the process differently.