Question 360
An auditee makes several claims after this quality audit observation: A manufacturer replaces defective labels but does not investigate why the labeling system failed. Which proposed claim is least defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Replacing one defective output necessarily prevents the same underlying failure recurring. The unsupported claim would obscure the quality problem. The more defensible action is: Distinguish immediate correction from investigation and elimination of underlying causes. This can be tested by: Inspect containment evidence, cause analysis, planned actions and effectiveness tests.
Incorrect Answers
Use this proportionate audit response: Distinguish immediate correction from investigation and elimination of underlying causes. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: Replacing one defective output necessarily prevents the same underlying failure recurring.
Check the following evidence: Inspect containment evidence, cause analysis, planned actions and effectiveness tests. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: Replacing one defective output necessarily prevents the same underlying failure recurring.
Apply this quality-audit principle: Correction addresses an observed issue, while corrective action aims to reduce recurrence. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: Replacing one defective output necessarily prevents the same underlying failure recurring.