Question 300
An auditee makes several claims after this quality audit observation: A plant attributes repeated misprints to operator carelessness despite inconsistent machine settings. Which proposed claim is least defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The first plausible explanation offered by management is automatically the true root cause. The unsupported claim would obscure the quality problem. The more defensible action is: Challenge proposed causes against timeline, process controls, evidence and competing explanations. This can be tested by: Review failure patterns, parameter changes, interviews and controlled tests.
Incorrect Answers
Use this proportionate audit response: Challenge proposed causes against timeline, process controls, evidence and competing explanations. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: The first plausible explanation offered by management is automatically the true root cause.
Check the following evidence: Review failure patterns, parameter changes, interviews and controlled tests. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: The first plausible explanation offered by management is automatically the true root cause.
Apply this quality-audit principle: Root-cause analysis should use evidence rather than settle for convenient attribution. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: The first plausible explanation offered by management is automatically the true root cause.