Question 220
An auditee makes several claims after this quality audit observation: A plant supervisor suppresses customer-return data to protect a production bonus while leadership praises quality culture. Which proposed claim is least defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Annual ethics training proves a quality culture even when managers routinely conceal unfavorable data. The unsupported claim would obscure the quality problem. The more defensible action is: Evaluate leadership behavior, reporting freedom, incentives and ethical treatment of adverse quality information. This can be tested by: Corroborate employee reports, escalation histories, incentive measures and management responses.
Incorrect Answers
Use this proportionate audit response: Evaluate leadership behavior, reporting freedom, incentives and ethical treatment of adverse quality information. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: Annual ethics training proves a quality culture even when managers routinely conceal unfavorable data.
Check the following evidence: Corroborate employee reports, escalation histories, incentive measures and management responses. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: Annual ethics training proves a quality culture even when managers routinely conceal unfavorable data.
Apply this quality-audit principle: A functioning quality culture requires behavior and accountability consistent with stated values. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: Annual ethics training proves a quality culture even when managers routinely conceal unfavorable data.