Question 120
An auditee makes several claims after this quality audit observation: A draft finding says the quality manager is careless but cites no objective condition. Which proposed claim is least defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
An emotive accusation is sufficient evidence of nonconformity. The unsupported claim would obscure the quality problem. The more defensible action is: Write a factual statement of requirement, observed condition and supporting evidence without personal judgment. This can be tested by: Inspect the cited criteria, sample IDs, actual records and unbiased wording.
Incorrect Answers
Use this proportionate audit response: Write a factual statement of requirement, observed condition and supporting evidence without personal judgment. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: An emotive accusation is sufficient evidence of nonconformity.
Check the following evidence: Inspect the cited criteria, sample IDs, actual records and unbiased wording. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: An emotive accusation is sufficient evidence of nonconformity.
Apply this quality-audit principle: Clear findings are traceable to requirements and facts, not personal criticism. This does not constitute the unsupported assumption; the assumption at issue is: An emotive accusation is sufficient evidence of nonconformity.