Question 160
During an outsourced-services renewal at a logistics group, the IS auditor learns that the quality program only counts reports issued and ignores evidence defects. The affected operation supports freight tracking and fleet operations. Delivery commitments and partner data flow through this process. Which weakness is MOST material to the control objective in this situation?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Correct. Inadequate engagement quality control can allow unsupported findings and repeat process weaknesses to persist. The described exception is: the quality program only counts reports issued and ignores evidence defects. This risk ties the observation to the business significance of freight tracking and fleet operations, rather than treating management's claim as independent assurance.
Incorrect Answers
Stakeholders may rely on a conclusion that exceeds the engagement objectives, criteria or evidence actually obtained. It does not establish the requested evidence appropriate to the audit conclusion outcome.
Audit resources may fail to address the systems and exposures most material to organizational objectives. The relevant success criterion is evidence appropriate to the audit conclusion; this measures a different function.
Insufficiently reliable or relevant evidence can cause an auditor to accept controls that did not operate as described. That result could pass without demonstrating evidence appropriate to the audit conclusion.