Question 70
A manufacturing transformation reports attractive individual ROI values, but workforce transition costs were excluded from the portfolio outcome. The board expects current evidence of combined portfolio value, capacity and delivery impact. Which proposed shortcut should the portfolio manager REJECT as the LEAST defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The shortcut to reject is: Add project ROI percentages together and omit shared transition expenses from the total. It would undermine the control in the reported case: A manufacturing transformation reports attractive individual ROI values, but workforce transition costs were excluded from the portfolio outcome. The governing evidence supports this choice: Add project ROI percentages together and omit shared transition expenses from the total.
Incorrect Answers
The option describes a different design statement: seek and implement the properly scoped portfolio response through authorized governance: Recalculate consolidated portfolio net value and disclose assumptions for governance decisions. The shortcut that conflicts with the case is add project ROI percentages together and omit shared transition expenses from the total.
This describes a way to verify a result, not a shortcut that defeats the control: confirm the response through traceable acceptance evidence: An auditable portfolio-level net-benefits estimate reconciles shared costs and avoids double counting. The question calls for rejecting add project ROI percentages together and omit shared transition expenses from the total. Demonstrating and recording the portfolio outcome strengthens assurance rather than defeating it.
The option describes a different design statement: gather decision-relevant evidence before acting: Examine shared transition expenses, avoided costs and duplicate benefit claims across components. The shortcut that conflicts with the case is add project ROI percentages together and omit shared transition expenses from the total.