Question 390
A public energy portfolio has citizen groups worried about land impacts but only investor reports have been issued. Different stakeholder groups have defined needs, influence and information-access rights. Which proposed shortcut should the portfolio manager REJECT as the LEAST defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The shortcut to reject is: Dismiss community concerns because they are not recorded in the finance benefits model. It would undermine the control in the reported case: A public energy portfolio has citizen groups worried about land impacts but only investor reports have been issued. Different stakeholder groups have defined needs, influence and information-access rights. The governing evidence supports this choice: Dismiss community concerns because they are not recorded in the finance benefits model.
Incorrect Answers
The option describes a different design statement: seek and implement the properly scoped portfolio response through authorized governance: Hold structured consultation, respond to material feedback and report how it informed portfolio governance. The shortcut that conflicts with the case is dismiss community concerns because they are not recorded in the finance benefits model. For the stated question the stronger answer is: Dismiss community concerns because they are not recorded in the finance benefits model.
This describes a way to verify a result, not a shortcut that defeats the control: confirm the response through traceable acceptance evidence: Documented engagement responses, adjusted decisions where justified and follow-up confidence measures. The question calls for rejecting dismiss community concerns because they are not recorded in the finance benefits model. Demonstrating and recording the portfolio outcome strengthens assurance rather than defeating it.
The option describes a different design statement: gather decision-relevant evidence before acting: Compare community concerns, environmental evidence and consultation commitments against the current roadmap. The shortcut that conflicts with the case is dismiss community concerns because they are not recorded in the finance benefits model. For the stated question the stronger answer is: Dismiss community concerns because they are not recorded in the finance benefits model.