Question 320
In a separately governed portfolio decision exercise, a comparable condition is examined: A city utility loses a long-standing subsidy and shifts its strategic objective from expansion to cash preservation. An independent strategy-review forum is conducting a comparable what-if analysis with an auditable decision trail. Which proposed shortcut should the portfolio manager REJECT as the LEAST defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The shortcut to reject is: Cut every project's budget by the same percentage without considering strategic value or termination costs. It would undermine the control in the reported case: In a separately governed portfolio decision exercise, a comparable condition is examined: A city utility loses a long-standing subsidy and shifts its strategic objective from expansion to cash preservation. The governing evidence supports this choice: Cut every project's budget by the same percentage without considering strategic value or termination costs.
Incorrect Answers
The option describes a different design statement: seek and implement the properly scoped portfolio response through authorized governance: Reevaluate portfolio scenarios and escalate a funding-sensitive rebalance with explicit commitments and cash-flow effects. The shortcut that conflicts with the case is cut every project's budget by the same percentage without considering strategic value or termination costs.
This describes a way to verify a result, not a shortcut that defeats the control: confirm the response through traceable acceptance evidence: A governance-approved rebalanced portfolio that meets liquidity limits and records the costs of cancellations. The question calls for rejecting cut every project's budget by the same percentage without considering strategic value or termination costs. Demonstrating and recording the portfolio outcome strengthens assurance rather than defeating it.
The option describes a different design statement: gather decision-relevant evidence before acting: Review approved cash thresholds, contractual termination liabilities and remaining benefits of current components. The shortcut that conflicts with the case is cut every project's budget by the same percentage without considering strategic value or termination costs.