Question 130
In a separately governed portfolio decision exercise, a comparable condition is examined: A payment-services organization changes strategy from market expansion to fraud loss reduction midway through the year. An independent strategy-review forum is conducting a comparable what-if analysis with an auditable decision trail. Which proposed shortcut should the portfolio manager REJECT as the LEAST defensible?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The shortcut to reject is: Keep all expansion initiatives because approving them previously made the original portfolio immutable. It would undermine the control in the reported case: In a separately governed portfolio decision exercise, a comparable condition is examined: A payment-services organization changes strategy from market expansion to fraud loss reduction midway through the year. The governing evidence supports this choice: Keep all expansion initiatives because approving them previously made the original portfolio immutable.
Incorrect Answers
This describes a way to verify a result, not a shortcut that defeats the control: confirm the response through traceable acceptance evidence: A revised approved portfolio roadmap with measurable fraud-reduction benefits and documented component dispositions. The question calls for rejecting keep all expansion initiatives because approving them previously made the original portfolio immutable. Demonstrating and recording the portfolio outcome strengthens assurance rather than defeating it.
The option describes a different design statement: gather decision-relevant evidence before acting: Check new fraud-loss targets against each in-flight component's remaining cost, benefits and exit constraints. The shortcut that conflicts with the case is keep all expansion initiatives because approving them previously made the original portfolio immutable. For the stated question the stronger answer is: Keep all expansion initiatives because approving them previously made the original portfolio immutable.
The option describes a different design statement: seek and implement the properly scoped portfolio response through authorized governance: Run a change-impact analysis and recommend retain, reshape, defer or stop decisions through portfolio governance. The shortcut that conflicts with the case is keep all expansion initiatives because approving them previously made the original portfolio immutable. For the stated question the stronger answer is: Keep all expansion initiatives because approving them previously made the original portfolio immutable.