Question 640
A CRISC practitioner challenges this decision or condition: An organization responds to a data subject access request by exporting all database rows including information about other individuals. Which false assumption creates the most directly relevant risk?
Explanation
Correct Answer
A privacy request does not justify indiscriminate disclosure of other people's data. This is the most relevant misleading shortcut for the scenario. Investigate by doing the following: Examine request scope, identity verification, exemptions and third-party information. A safe treatment is: Implement a privacy-preserving access workflow that filters and redacts unrelated records.
Incorrect Answers
Possession of personal data does not authorize every later secondary use. That would matter when a marketing platform collects location data for service delivery but reuses it for unrelated profiling without evaluating the lawful purpose. The relevant distinction in this case is: A privacy request does not justify indiscriminate disclosure of other people's data.
Encryption without suitable key custody may not prevent unauthorized disclosure. That would matter when a bank accepts a processor's assertion that customer records are encrypted but cannot establish who has decryption-key access. It does not address this case's requirement: An organization responds to a data subject access request by exporting all database rows including information about other individuals.
Payroll employment status does not determine whether a user creates security risk. That would matter when a call center's contractors are excluded from security awareness even though they handle sensitive customer information. That separate mechanism does not verify the needed risk management outcome in this case.