Question 40
Before recommending action, an analyst encounters the following: A security team reports that it performed its own independent audit of controls it designed and operates. Which check would best clarify the key uncertainty?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Examine control operation, second-line challenge and independent assurance reporting lines. This is the most direct prerequisite to validate before choosing a response. The intended controlled action is: Separate first-line management, second-line oversight and independent third-line assurance roles. Success should ultimately show: The audit opinion comes from an independent function without responsibility for operating the control.
Incorrect Answers
Compare second-line advisory mandate with risk acceptance authority and board delegation. That would matter when a risk committee allows risk assessors to accept all high-risk exceptions without business-owner review. The relevant distinction in this case is: Examine control operation, second-line challenge and independent assurance reporting lines.
Inspect first-line monitoring responsibilities, assurance scope and audit cadence. That would matter when a board assumes an external audit replaces management's obligation to monitor risk continuously. It does not address this case's requirement: A security team reports that it performed its own independent audit of controls it designed and operates.
Review first-line control owner responsibilities and the risk office's oversight charter. That would matter when a second-line risk office is directly approving every firewall change instead of challenging operational decisions. That separate mechanism does not verify the needed risk management outcome in this case.