Question 450
A CRISC practitioner is evaluating this situation: A backup encryption control lowers unauthorized disclosure risk but does not reduce ransomware-driven availability loss. What evidence should be examined FIRST to establish the relevant risk or control condition?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Compare control effectiveness against confidentiality and availability loss pathways separately. This is the most direct prerequisite to validate before choosing a response. The intended controlled action is: Rate residual risks by consequence type rather than assuming one safeguard reduces all impact. Success should ultimately show: The risk record shows confidentiality improvement but retains realistic availability exposure.
Incorrect Answers
Review pre-control loss scenario, redundancy evidence and remaining common dependencies. That would matter when a SaaS service has an estimated inherent outage loss of $2 million but a redundant provider reduces, not eliminates, the exposure. The relevant distinction in this case is: Compare control effectiveness against confidentiality and availability loss pathways separately.
Review control effectiveness, independent evidence and calibrated risk methodology. That would matter when a manufacturer treats residual risk as equal to the inherent risk score minus the number of installed security controls. It does not address this case's requirement: A backup encryption control lowers unauthorized disclosure risk but does not reduce ransomware-driven availability loss.
Reassess existing mitigations, changed information flow and risk appetite. That would matter when an accepted residual privacy risk increases after an external processor expands data sharing beyond the agreed scope. That separate mechanism does not verify the needed risk management outcome in this case.