Question 380
A CRISC practitioner is evaluating this situation: A compliance program selects controls from two frameworks but maps them to inconsistent business requirements. What evidence should be examined FIRST to establish the relevant risk or control condition?
Explanation
Correct Answer
Compare overlapping control objectives, obligations and existing control catalog references. This is the most direct prerequisite to validate before choosing a response. The intended controlled action is: Establish a unified control taxonomy mapping requirements to actual control objectives. Success should ultimately show: Auditors can trace each binding requirement to tested controls without duplication.
Incorrect Answers
Compare preventive versus detective timing and the maximum tolerable fraud loss. That would matter when a fraud prevention team treats monthly reconciliation as its only mitigation for real-time fraudulent transactions. The relevant distinction in this case is: Compare overlapping control objectives, obligations and existing control catalog references.
Identify the risk event, attack path and which control layer mitigates it. That would matter when a company uses a physical mantrap as evidence that application data is protected against unauthorized API calls. It does not address this case's requirement: A compliance program selects controls from two frameworks but maps them to inconsistent business requirements.
Examine whether the control blocks, detects or corrects an event and its design objective. That would matter when a security architect deploys an intrusion detection tool but labels it a preventive control because it sends alerts. That separate mechanism does not verify the needed risk management outcome in this case.