Question 680
A campus and WAN design workshop reports: A manufacturing campus buys point-to-point Ethernet links for twenty buildings but plans to treat the collection as a single broadcast mesh without loop controls. What is the most relevant cause of the design failure?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The relevant principle is: Multipoint Ethernet services and many independent E-Line circuits have different Layer 2 forwarding and spanning-tree implications. A valid architectural response is: Choose appropriate Metro Ethernet point-to-point or multipoint service topology with explicit VLAN and loop-avoidance design. The expected evidence is: Test circuits deliver intended Ethernet frames while deliberate redundant paths avoid persistent broadcast loops.
Incorrect Answers
Ordinary port-level upgrades may not meet aggregate fiber-capacity and distance requirements when the optical transport must host many independent wavelengths. “Evaluate supported DWDM wavelengths, optics, optical budget, dispersion and protection channels for the transport design” would remedy that alternative situation, but it would not correct the present issue: multipoint Ethernet services and many independent E-Line circuits have different Layer 2 forwarding and spanning-tree implications.
“Select a supported MPLS L3VPN design using separate VPN routing tables and approved route-target import/export policy” is the supported response when a shared provider routing domain cannot preserve independent overlapping tenant address spaces and route targets without isolation. Here the decisive response is “Choose appropriate Metro Ethernet point-to-point or multipoint service topology with explicit VLAN and loop-avoidance design”, so that different intervention does not meet the stated requirement.
Mobile backup is useful only if real coverage, policy, cost and failure independence support required branch services. “Design cellular failover with tested signal strength, provider diversity, data-plan capacity and selective critical traffic routing” applies to that other condition. The reported evidence is a manufacturing campus buys point-to-point Ethernet links for twenty buildings but plans to treat the collection as a single broadcast mesh without loop controls; this alternative would address the wrong dependency.