Question 580
A campus and WAN design workshop reports: A branch sends 1 Gbps bursts into an Ethernet handoff while its provider contract allows only 100 Mbps and drops excess traffic unpredictably. What governance check would most directly reduce future risk?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This design guardrail addresses qos shaping on provider lower rate link: A high-speed physical port does not imply equal committed service rate, so uncontrolled bursts can be discarded in the provider network. Long-term prevention is: Revalidate shaping rates against provider CIR and accounting overhead after circuit or device changes. A generic control for another failure mode is insufficient.
Incorrect Answers
Policing enforces a rate by dropping or remarking excess packets, whereas shaping ordinarily smooths outbound bursts using buffers. “Document burst tolerance and discard implications when choosing policing or shaping for each class” would remedy that alternative situation, but it would not correct the present issue: a high-speed physical port does not imply equal committed service rate, so uncontrolled bursts can be discarded in the provider network.
“Audit QoS trust maps when onboarding new endpoint types or enabling unmanaged switch ports” is the supported response when trusting unvalidated endpoint DSCP markings allows unauthorized traffic to consume preferential network resources. Here the decisive response is “Revalidate shaping rates against provider CIR and accounting overhead after circuit or device changes”, so that different intervention does not meet the stated requirement.
An oversized or unbounded strict-priority queue can consume interface capacity and deny adequate service to other classes. “Review queue bandwidth guarantees and peak-rate policing as service demand changes” applies to that other condition. The reported evidence is a branch sends 1 Gbps bursts into an Ethernet handoff while its provider contract allows only 100 Mbps and drops excess traffic unpredictably; this alternative would address the wrong dependency.