Question 260
A campus and WAN design workshop reports: Two redundant distribution switches both believe they are HSRP active after a VLAN trunk blocks hello messages, causing inconsistent gateway ARP responses. What is the most relevant cause of the design failure?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The relevant principle is: FHRP peers must exchange control messages in a correctly shared VLAN to maintain a single active forwarding role. A valid architectural response is: Restore approved VLAN trunk reachability and compatible HSRP group and timer settings across both devices. The expected evidence is: The peer pair displays one active and one standby role, and a client resolves a stable virtual gateway MAC.
Incorrect Answers
A single physical gateway address makes host access depend on one distribution device even when a second gateway exists. “Design a supported FHRP virtual gateway with aligned priorities, Layer 2 reachability and safe failover between distribution switches” would remedy that alternative situation, but it would not correct the present issue: FHRP peers must exchange control messages in a correctly shared VLAN to maintain a single active forwarding role.
“Choose a documented VRRP preemption design with safe delay and reachability tracking that fits service stability goals” is the supported response when gateway role restoration depends on the selected FHRP protocol and its configured preemption settings, not priority numbers alone. Here the decisive response is “Restore approved VLAN trunk reachability and compatible HSRP group and timer settings across both devices”, so that different intervention does not meet the stated requirement.
FHRP presence alone may not account for upstream path viability without appropriate object or interface tracking. “Track the required upstream path and decrement priority enough for a healthy standby gateway to assume forwarding” applies to that other condition. The reported evidence is two redundant distribution switches both believe they are HSRP active after a VLAN trunk blocks hello messages, causing inconsistent gateway ARP responses; this alternative would address the wrong dependency.