Question 1
During a resilience simulation, the architecture team notes: A large enterprise collects SNMP interface counters using a shared SNMPv2 community across all regions and must meet per-user authentication and privacy controls. Which analysis best identifies the architectural gap?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The relevant principle is: Legacy community strings do not provide SNMPv3's user-based authentication and encryption capabilities needed by the policy. A valid architectural response is: Design supported SNMPv3 users, auth/privacy mechanisms, least-privilege views and central credential lifecycle. The expected evidence is: Authorized monitors receive counters through protected requests while invalid user or authentication parameters are rejected.
Incorrect Answers
In-band-only management can share a fault with the network being repaired, eliminating the ability to recover remotely. “Provide secure out-of-band management through independent transport, power and authentication suitable for critical nodes” would remedy that alternative situation, but it would not correct the present issue: legacy community strings do not provide SNMPv3's user-based authentication and encryption capabilities needed by the policy.
“Design redundant remote syslog collectors with protected transport, appropriate facilities and retention controls” is the supported response when local log storage and rollover cannot substitute for reliable centralized timestamped security event retention. Here the decisive response is “Design supported SNMPv3 users, auth/privacy mechanisms, least-privilege views and central credential lifecycle”, so that different intervention does not meet the stated requirement.
A common routing table broadens the management attack surface and increases risk of route or ACL leakage. “Create a supported management VRF or equivalent separated context and tightly controlled shared services as needed” applies to that other condition. The reported evidence is a large enterprise collects SNMP interface counters using a shared SNMPv2 community across all regions and must meet per-user authentication and privacy controls; this alternative would address the wrong dependency.