Question 1
A reviewer is challenging several proposals for this case: A monthly reconciliation succeeds only when one senior analyst manually fixes every discrepancy. Which proposal should be rejected because it most directly violates the case's control objective?
Explanation
Correct Answer
“Call the process mature because the same expert always rescues it.” undermines the intended safeguard. A capability is not repeatable if outcomes depend on one individual's heroics. Document, automate where justified and test repeatable processes and backups. Run controlled handover and recurrence tests using trained alternate staff.
Incorrect Answers
“Document the repeatability versus heroics decision, its owner, limitations and a review date before closure.” records a controlled change and supports accountable evaluation. A capability is not repeatable if outcomes depend on one individual's heroics. Run controlled handover and recurrence tests using trained alternate staff.
Document, automate where justified and test repeatable processes and backups. A capability is not repeatable if outcomes depend on one individual's heroics. Run controlled handover and recurrence tests using trained alternate staff.
Run controlled handover and recurrence tests using trained alternate staff. A capability is not repeatable if outcomes depend on one individual's heroics. Document, automate where justified and test repeatable processes and backups.